Executive Connection Newsletter:
Issue 75, SEPTEMBER 2006
| DICK
WRAY EXECUTIVE SEARCH - MONTHLY EDITORIAL |
SAY IT ISN’T SO…..EVEN CHEESECAKE
IS DOWN!
Written by Bob Gershberg, Managing
Partner, Dick Wray Executive Search
Mother always said, “There is a bright side
to everything!” The exorbitant price of filling
the SUV tank is taking a substantive toll on the casual
dining segment. In the second quarter, 18 casual chains
posted negative growth compared to 8 in the same quarter
last year. Stock prices for the publicly traded casual
chains are hovering at 52 week lows. Same-store sales
are down at Chili’s, Applebee’s, Red Lobster,
Outback and now the ever-ascending P.F. Chang’s
and Cheesecake Factory as well.
Where is the silver lining? Who will the beneficiaries
of this unprecedented tumble be? As a result of “trading
down” on the part of cash pressed consumers,
the Quick Service Restaurant (QSR) sector appears to
be getting an assist from the struggles of its big
brothers in casual, but on further analysis only enough
to prevent their own slide. The fast casual segment
is the clear winner, finally receiving its hard earned
due. If the fast casuals continue to deliver on the
value proposition, their growth will be exponential.
Trendy, quick, often ethnic with a healthier premium
perception, the fast casual chains are poised for success.
According to Technomic Information Services, this
$11 billion arena has shown the following per segment
growth:
- Mexican – 18%
- Bakery/Café – 21%
- Chicken – 20%
Beneficiary #1 is inarguably the fast casual gang.
Panera, Chipotle and El Pollo Loco – ROCK ON!
Beneficiary #2 is the consumer, no doubt. Adversity
brings out the best in our industry and always has.
The casual dining gang is very busy getting better
yet again. Lower prices, more exciting menu choices,
and remodeled units are just the beginning. The fine
folks at Outback appear to have told their pesky hedge
fund to take a hike and it appears that is just what
they did. Watching the best and brightest in our industry
raise the bar is always great viewing.
All the best,

Bob Gershberg | Managing Partner Dick Wray
Executive Search
bob.gershberg@dickwray.com
“Dick Wray
Executive Search – Maintaining the same ethical
recruiting standards for over 34 years.”
|
| EXECUTIVE
MOVEMENT |
|
OONA SETTEMBRE has been hired as the new director
of culinary research and development for ON THE BORDER
MEXICAN GRILL AND CANTINA, a 50-plus-unit chain operated
by BRINKER INTERNATIONAL. Settembre was formerly corporate
chef of DAVE & BUSTER’S.
Yum! Brands veteran ROBB CHASE has been named to the
newly created post of president PAPA JOHN’S INTERNATIONAL
INC.’s international division. Papa John’s
International Inc. is the owner of the 2,924-unit pizza
brand. President of Papa John’s domestic arm,
WILLIAM VAN EPPS, had been overseeing the 350-unit
international division which has outlets in 24 countries.
Prior to his appointment, Chase was president and chief
executive of Famous Players, a division of Viacom and
a leading Canadian theatrical exhibition company and
before that he was senior vice president of international
franchising at Tricon Global Restaurants, now called
Yum! Brands, parent of Pizza Hut, KFC and other brands.
DAVE GOEBEL, president and chief operating officer
of APPLEBEE’S INTERNATIONAL INC., was promoted
to the position of chief executive effective this month
and replaces LLOYD HILL, who will continue as non-executive
chairman of the board. While Goebel’s successor
as president or COO has not been named, it is expected
that at least one of the posts will be filled by CARIN
STUTZ, currently executive vice president of operations.
MCDONALD’S CORP. named RALPH ALVAREZ to president
and chief operating officer following the resignation
of MIKE ROBERTS, who was with the company for 29 years.
A report last month in The Chicago Tribune indicated
that Roberts’ resignation was due to the company’s
refusal to provide him with a definite timetable for
succeeding chief executive, JIM SKINNER. The former
executive vice president and COO of McDonald’s
USA, DON THOMPSON, will succeed Alvarez. Two other
executives also were promoted to leadership positions.
Assuming the role of executive vice president and chief
operating officer of McDonald’s USA is JANICE
FIELDS. She replaces DON THOMPSON who was elevated
to the position of president of McDonald’s North
American division. Previously, Fields served as president
of the central division for McDonald’s USA. Her
replacement is JAMES JOHANNESEN, who was serving as
senior vice president and chief support officer for
McDonald’s USA.
PETER ROBINSON, was named by BURGER KING CORP., the
11,100-plus unit chain, to Burger King’s Europe,
the Middle East and Africa division, known as EMEA
and will replace STEVE DESUTTER, who resigned last
month. Prior to this appointment, Robinson served as
president of Pillsbury USA and senior vice president
of General Mills Inc. He will be based at the EMEA
headquarters in Zug, Switzerland.
Chief operating officer of Yum! Brands, DAVID DENO,
will become a managing director in October of CCMP
CAPITAL ADVISORS LLC, the newly formed private-equity
firm participating in the $8.3 billion buyout of Philadelphia-based
contractor ARAMARK CORP. A press release issued by
PEET’S COFFEE & TEA INC. told of the pending
affiliation when they announced that Deno has been
appointed to the board of the Emeryville, Calif.-based
coffee roaster and retailer.
RUBIO’S FRESH MEXICAN GRILL, the 150-unit fast-casual
chain, named DANIEL PITARD president and chief executive
officer. He succeeds SHERI MIKSA, who resigned in December
2005 to pursue other interests. Pittard, a private
investor, held executive positions for consulting group
McKinsey & Co., PepsiCo Inc. and Amoco Corp., which
is now part of BP. During the late 1990s, he served
as chief strategic officer of the computer company,
Gateway Inc., and was responsible for acquisitions
and new ventures. RALPH RUBIO, the chain’s co-founder,
who has served as interim president and chief executive,
remains chairman of the board. Rubio said, “With
a proven record of strategic vision, financial acumen
and operational success, Dan is an outstanding addition
to lead our executive management team. I look forward
to working with him to successfully grow our brand.”
E. MICHAEL MURPHY was promoted by CKE RESTAURANTS
INC., parent of the CARL’S JR., HARDEE’S
and LA SALSA FRESH MEXICAN GRILL chains, to chief administrative
officer and NED LYERLY was promoted to senior vice
president of global franchise development. In addition
to his new responsibilities leading the legal, human
resources, payroll and information technology departments,
Murphy will continue to serve as general counsel and
executive vice president, overseeing franchising, which
he has done since 2000. Lyerly will expand on his responsibilities
as senior vice president of the company’s international
division in his new role.
DOUGLAS REIFSCHNEIDER, a quick-service and casual
dining marketing veteran, was named by FIREHOUSE SUBS
as marketing director for the 237-unit chain. Reifschneider
succeeds BEVERLY JELINEK, who joined Goodwill Industries
earlier this year. He was formerly field marketing
director for Fazoli’s Management Inc.
Three employees were promoted to the roles of vice
presidents of their respective divisions by GARDEN
FRESH RESTAURANT CORP., parent company of 97 buffet
restaurants under the SOUPLANTATION and SWEET TOMATOES.
RICHARD THOMSON was named vice president of management
information systems; SUSAN HOFFMAN was promoted to
vice president of the food procurement department;
and STEVE DURLER was named vice president of construction.
MICHAEL MACK, chief executive of Garden Fresh Restaurant
said, “Our employees are our most valuable asset
and it is a great pleasure to watch them grow with
the company. Richard, Susan and Steve have been instrumental
to the success of Garden Fresh and we are ecstatic
that they will continue to help move our company forward.”
JOHN TESAR was named by MANSION ON TURTLE CREEK hotel
to succeed DEAN FEARING as executive chef. Most recently,
Tesar served as executive chef of rm restaurant at
the Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino in Las Vegas under
RICK MOONEN. Fearing is joining the Dallas Ritz-Carlton
currently under construction.
PERRY SHOLES was hired as vice president of crew resources
for RAISING CANE’S CHICKEN FINGERS, which is
owner or franchisor of 47 quick-service restaurants.
A native of New Orleans, Sholes joined Raising Cane’s
from Kraft Foods, where he directed human resources
for the company’s Latin American region.
DAVE CAVALLIN has been promoted to finance vice president
for LOGAN’S ROADHOUSE INC. the 166-unit casual
steakhouse division of CBRL GROUP INC. and will oversee
capital budgeting, purchasing analysis and operations
finance. Cavallin will still report to senior vice
president of accounting and finance, AMY BERTAUSKI.
Prior to this move, he was senior finance director.
SCOTT LIPPITT, 47, was fired from QUIZNOS SUB, the
4,400-unit sandwich chain after he was arrested for
allegedly using the Internet to arrange a sexual encounter
with a 13-year-old girl. Lippitt was Quiznos executive
vice president of marketing. In an statement issued
by Quiznos following Lippitt’s arrest, Quiznos
said that it decided to terminate him after conducting
its own investigation.
PETER P. HAUSBACK was hired as chief financial officer
by GRANITE CITY FOOD & BREWERY LTD., operator of
14 namesake brewpub-restaurants in seven Midwestern
states, and will succeed DANIEL H. BAUER, who resigned
in order to remain in Atlanta with his family. Hausback
most recently was VP and chief accounting officer of
NightHawk Radiology Holdings Inc. and a key player
in its IPO. Additionally, he was finance vice president
and CFO of Il Fornaio (America) Corp., the upscale
Italian restaurant-bakery chain and served as VP and
CFO of WestCoast Hospitality Corp., operator and franchisor
of lodging and entertainment services.
TODD IMMEL was named restaurant chef at TABLE 1280,
the 220-seat fine-dining brasserie and tapas lounge
located in Atlanta. He fills a post vacated by Shaun
Doty who left to debut his newest neighborhood concept,
Shaun’s, in midtown Atlanta. Immel previously
worked as executive chef at Luma restaurant in Winter
Park, Fla. New York-based RESTAURANT ASSOCIATES, a
unit of British conglomerate COMPASS GROUP PLC, operates
Table 1280.
|
| NEWS
|
|
A securities filing by BURGER KING HOLDINGS
INC . disclosed that it was sued July 24
in California Superior Court under the state’s
Proposition 65 warning statute for allegedly failing
to disclose to customers that flame broiled BK burgers
could contain a cancer-causing agent, POLYCYCLIC
AROMATIC HYDROCARBONS, or PAHs. If found
liable, Burger King said that it could be required
to pay penalties and provide injunctive relief. While
the amount of damages sought by LEEMAN V.
BURGER KING CORP. , was not disclosed,the
Miami company said, “It is not possible to
ascertain with any degree of any confidence the amount
of our financial exposure, if any.”
RICK SPIROS , chef of BLOCK
44, received a warning letter from the
health department in the first reported enforcement
action under Chicago’s new ban on sales of
foie gras. If a second violation occurs, Block faces
a fine of $250. According to Spiros, he served about
eight orders of foie gras three days after the effective
date of the much-publicized ban which was after he
had purchased the expensive liver, in order not to
waste it. There is a pending lawsuit filed by the ILLINOIS
RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION and a chefs’ coalition
challenging the ban.
Private-equity company, CATTERTON PARTNERS, and
venture capital firm, OAK INVESTMENT PARTNERS, have
acquired the parent of the Cheddar’s Casual Cafe
and Fish Daddy’s chains. Cheddar’s president, DOUG
ROGERS, and chief operating officer, GREG
GOOD, would continue in their roles. Previously,
Catterton and Oak invested together in P.F. Chang’s
China Bistro, Baja Fresh Mexican Grill, Caribou Coffee
and La Madeleine French Bakery Café.
QUAD-C MANAGEMENT has bought an
undisclosed stake in STICKY FINGERS CORP.of
Mount Pleasant, S.C. indicating that private equity
firms are keen on investing in smaller restaurant companies.
Quad-C had previous investments in Red Robin Gourmet
Burgers, Huddle House, and Caribbean Restaurants, a
Burger King franchisee with units in Puerto Rico and
the U.S. Virgin Islands.
Hedge fund PIRATE CAPITAL LLC sold
its 5.3-percent stake that it held in OSI RESTAURANT
PARTNERS INC. Previously Pirate had threatened
OSI with a proxy fight for board control unless the
parent of Outback Steakhouse divested some smaller
chains and urged OSI’s board to halt development
of the Outback brand and spin off the Carrabba’s
Italian Grill, Fleming’s Prime Steakhouse & Wine
Bar and Bonefish Grill chains to boost shareholder
value. Pirate declined to divulge the price it sold
at or when and only said that it had divested all of
its 3.9 million beneficially owned shares of OSI stock.
C . STEPHEN LYNN, former SONIC
CORP. and SHONEY’S
INC. chairman and chief executive, along
with a group of others, offered to buy the outstanding
shares it doesn’t already hold in BACK
YARD BURGERS INC. at $6.10 per share. BBAC
LLC of Atlanta already owns an 8.8-percent
stake in the Memphis-based operator and franchisor
of 172 restaurants in 20 Southern and Midwestern
states. CHEROKEE ADVISORS LLC and
its managing member, REID ZEISING, are
part of the BBAC group whose offer was rebuffed this
past June by Back Yard Burgers in an earlier buyout
proposal. However, Back Yard Burgers decided not
to pursue the offer saying it was “unacceptable” to
Back Yard’s board and the proposal itself would
not be reviewed.
Making it the first major quick-service chain to
switch to a non-hydrogenated cooking oil, WENDY’S
INTERNATIONAL INC. has completed the transition
to using cooking oil with zero grams of trans fat per
serving at its 6,000 U.S. restaurants. IAN
ROWDEN, Wendy’s executive vice president
and chief marketing officer said, “We’ve
already served millions of servings of food cooked
in the new soy/corn oil blend with zero grams of trans
fat, and consumers have reaffirmed that there is absolutely
no difference in taste. Furthermore, the conversion
to the new oil has been cost-neutral to our system.” Most
of the Wendy’s restaurants in Canada re already
using the new oil.
A new prototype, SHAKEY’S PIZZA & GRILL,
is scheduled to open in Covina, California early this
month. Operated and franchised by SHAKEY’S
USA, the new test unit is part of a five-year
revitalization plan. There will not be a salad bar
or hot buffet at the new unit which is typically featured
at Shakey’s restaurants but it will have a small
game room for children. According to Shakey’s,
its 16 company-owned restaurants will be re-imaged
by the end 2008 and possibly 10-15 of the system’s
44 franchise units should be upgraded. There are also
plans to test the concept outside Southern California
in a new market, yet to be named.
During a meeting with officials with the Arizona
Cardinals, PETER MORTON, co-founder
of HARD ROCK CAFÉ, and his
son, HENRY MORTON presented an offer
of $3 million for rights to name the Arizona Cardinals’ football
stadium after the family’s newest restaurant
concept, PINK TACO, in which the younger
Morton serves as chief executive.
Reports of their acquisition of REAL MEX
RESTAURANTS INC ., parent of El Torito,
Chevys, Acapulco and 10 other ethnic concepts have
been confirmed by SUN CAPITAL PARTNERS INC.,
the private-equity company that owns the Bruegger’s,
Souplantation, Sweet Tomatoes and Souper Salad restaurant
chains. BRUCKMAN, ROSSER, SHERRILL & CO.,
whose portfolio includes stakes in Au Bon Pain, California
Pizza Kitchen and Bravo Development Corp., a 50-unit
Midwestern restaurant group held a majority interest
in Real Mex.
After a battle with lung cancer, longtime chief executive
and one time chairman, JACK LAUGHERY, of HARDEE’S, passed
away last month at age 71 from pneumonia. In 1972,
Laughery joined Hardee’s through its merger with
Sandy’s, a regional burger chain that he was
leading at the time. A year later, he was named president
and chief operating officer of Hardee’s. In 1975
he was named chief executive and held that post until
his retirement in 1990 when he then served as chairman
for the next four years. ANDREW PUDZER,
current president and chief executive of Hardee’s
said, “Our deepest sympathies go out to the Laughery
family, especially to his wife, HELEN,
and his four daughters. Jack will always be remembered
as a tireless leader and fast-food innovator.”
In a deal expected to be completed in the fourth
quarter this year, LONE STAR STEAKHOUSE & SALOON
INC ., operator and franchisor of 283 restaurants
under various brands, will be acquired by Dallas-based
private-equity firm LONE STAR FUNDS. The
transaction is valued at more than $600 million and
shareholders in the restaurant company would be paid
$27.10 per share in cash. The deal, still subject to
shareholder approval, was approved by the company’s
board of directors Aug. 18. However, BARINGTON
CAPITAL GROUP LP, an investment management
firm representing investors owning about 9.4 percent
of common stock said that a proposed $600 million takeover
deal undervalues the company. JAMES A. MITAROTONDA,
chairman and chief executive of Barington, said, “While
we are reserving for now our ultimate judgment on the
transaction, we do not believe that the company’s
valuable assets and brands are being sold for a price
that reflects the intrinsic value of the company.” In
mid-March, 30 underperforming namesake restaurants
were closed due to escalating net losses and falling
total sales at the affected locations. Lone Star Funds
is in the process of selling its current foodservice
holding, the 291-unit Shoney’s family restaurant
chain to private-equity firm Centrum Equities for an
undisclosed amount. That deal is expected to close
this month.
A 20-unit deal was approved last month between BAR-B-CUTIE
FRANCHISE SYSTEMS LLC, owner of the 50-year-old,
seven-unit BAR-B-CUTIE brand that
now operates in five states and FAMILY & FRIENDS
FOOD SL to open the first international
restaurant in Valencia, Spain. Barcelona and Madrid
are targeted for future openings as part of the 10
year agreement.
Two new franchise agreements were executed by TIJUANA
FLATS, a 47-unit fast-casual Tex-Mex chain.
The agreements call for 11 units to open in the Pittsburgh
area. Five units will be launched by TOM
FLANAGAN over the next three and a half
years. Burger King veteran, TIM AUVIL, along
with ANITA AUVIL, will open five
restaurants.
Based on preliminary results of a voluntary internal
audit, THE CHEESECAKE FACTORY INC. plans
to restate financial results at least for the fiscal
year ended Jan. 2 and the first quarter ended April
4 amid an inquiry by federal regulars into stock option
grants to its executives. The U.S.SECURITIES
AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION is also conducting
an investigation into their stock option granting practices.
The company stated said its fiscal 2005 10-K and first-quarter
2006 10-Q reports “should no longer be relied
upon” and that it had found a “range of
potential adjustments would likely be material to the
current year and possibly prior years.” The Cheesecake
Factory also noted that the “vast majority” of
option grants with apparently “incorrect” dates
resulting from “administrative oversight” were
made prior to June 30, 2002. They missed reporting
second-quarter financial results. Two shareholder groups
have also filed suit against the operator of 107 namesake
and seven Grand Lux Café in the state Superior
Court in Los Angeles alleging a breach of fiduciary
duty and unjust enrichment related to Cheesecake Factory’s
grants of options to executives. In July, Cheesecake
Factory said it had begun a voluntary review of its
option granting practices, and had retained outside
legal counsel to assist.
A franchise agreement was signed between RUBY
TUESDAY INC ., the 880-unit casual-dining
chain and RT RESTAURANTS SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA
LLC calling for RT to open 15 units over
the next five years in Southern California. National
Football League player JUNIOR SEAU,
who recently announced his retirement from the Miami
Dolphins, TED DAVENPORT, a Ruby
Tuesday franchisee for Hawaii since 2003 and a veteran
real estate developer, JEFF HOWIE, will
run the new franchise.
CAPTAIN D ’S, the
600-unit quick-service chain, has re-introduced itself
as a fast casual concept called CAPTAIN D’S
SEAFOOD KITCHEN. In addition to the new design
features including new seating and bolder graphics,
a new menu features choices such as catfish and shrimp
skewers, pasta dishes, blackened tilapia and seven
new sides. By year-end, the new Captain D’s Seafood
Kitchen logo will appear in ads and on packaging. Additionally,
the new logo will be featured on unit exteriors as
branches of the chain are remodeled over the next three
years.
According to published reports, TODD ENGLISH, chef-restaurateur,
has parted the way with investors in his FIGS restaurants
in Boston. While the Wellesley Figs would drop that
name and go to his former investors, including JIM
PALLOTTA, co-owner of the Boston Celtics,
English will get the Figs in Charlestown and Beacon
Hill. It is said that MICHAEL SCHLOW’s GUAPO
RESTAURANT GROUP is negotiating for the Wellesley
space.
Chef-owner GUENTER SEEGER is planning
to close the acclaimed SEEGER’S in
Atlanta and BOB AMICK, noted restaurateur,
is negotiating to buy a stake in the fine-dining landmark.
Amick, known for such Atlanta hotspots as One Midtown
Kitchen and Piebar, is co-founder of CONCENTRICS
HOSPITALITY.
WHITE HEN PANTRY INC ., the Lombard,
Ill.-based operator and franchisor of 261 C-stores
in the Chicago and Boston areas, has been acquired
by 7-ELEVEN INC., operator and franchisor
of more than 30,000 convenience stores worldwide, for
$35 million. New York-based private equity firm, ANGELO, GORDON & CO.,
held a controlling stake in White Hen. A subsidiary
of Japanese company SEVEN & I HOLDINGS
CO. LTD., 7-Eleven, said
the purchase would help “boost the efficiency” of
the chain’s infrastructure, including fresh-food
production facilities, considered key to a current
focus of 7-Eleven’s marketing. According to Nation’s
Restaurant News research, the chain’s 5,340 U.S.
stores generated foodservice sales of $1.56 billion
for 2005 with total sales of all kinds worldwide of
$43 billion last year. In a statement issued by 7-Eleven, “enhanced
customer recognition” is one of the acquisition’s
main objectives and White Hen units will continue to
operate under their current identity until they are
converted to the 7-Eleven format.
An informal inquiry by the U.S. Securities and Exchange
Commission into the history of the stock option granting
practices of CEC ENTERTAINMENT ,
owner of the Chuck E. Cheese’s brand, is underway.
Indications were that the company missed the Aug. 11
deadline for filing results for the quarter ended July
2 because its audit committee had not completed a previously
reported internal review of those practices. A number
of companies, including The Cheesecake Factory, are
under an SEC review as federal authorities look into
the possibility that officials at these companies may
have illegally backdated stock purchase options granted
to executives in order to boost their value.
During the course of the next four to five years,
the 61-unit breakfast-lunch only chain, FIRST
WATCH RESTAURANTS, based in Bradenton, Florida,
is planning to open 15 to 18 locations in the Washington,
D.C. market with the first unit scheduled to open last
month in Fairfax, VA.
Operator and franchisor of 2,065 namesake quick-service
restaurants, JACK IN THE BOX INC.,
will sell its 25 branches in Hawaii, most of which
are in Maui and Honolulu, to CHRIS SCANLAN, a
new franchisee and former president of Hawaii’s
largest operator of Burger King and KFC outlets. Scalan’s
company, SCANLAN MANAGEMENT LLC, also
agreed to open an unspecified number of additional
Jack in the Box outlets in the state, which has one
franchised branch, in Hilo. The sale is expected to
be finalized by the fourth quarter.
A LETTUCE ENTERTAIN YOU ENTERPRISES fine-dining
restaurant in Chicago, TRU, has converted
its small lounge into a caviar and appetizer bar. LEYE’s
chairman, RICHARD MELMAN, said, “It’s
caviar five ways and light appetizers.” Other
news at LEYE include plans to open a six-unit Wildfire,
a 1940s style steakhouse concept in Atlanta in the
fall with a second location scheduled for next year
in McLean, Virginia. Another LEYE concept, WOW
BAO, is scheduled to open in downtown Chicago
and is a steamed-Chinese-bun takeout stand. According
to Melman, LEYE is also talking with Harrah’s
Flamingo in Las Vegas for what is likely to be a new-style
buffet.
A three-unit Ruth’s Chris Steak House franchisee, DESERT
ISLAND RESTAURANTS, has signed restaurateur STEVE
HALLIDAY as the first franchisee of its LING & LOUIE’S
ASIAN BAR AND GRILL concept. Desert Island
Restaurant has the Thaifoon Taste of Asia concept
located in Scottsdale and Salt Lake City. According
to Desert Island, Halliday’s branch should
open by late October in Denver’s new Northfield
Stapleton Center.
Contract foodservice and management company, ARAMARK
CORP., has agreed to be acquired by an investment
group led by JOSEPH A. NEUBAUER, Aramark
CEO, for $8.3 billion, including the assumption or
repayment of about $2 billion in debt. Completion
of the transaction is expected to be completed by
early 2007. Last May, a private equity group offered
$32 per share, however, now stockholders will receive
$33.80 per share in cash. According to Aramark, its
board of directors unanimously accepted the revised
offer on the recommendation of a special advisory
committee of outside directors. According to a securities
filing, if for any reason the deal is not completed,
Aramark will have to pay, or will receive, $120 million.
The buyout group also includes GS CAPITAL, CCMP
CAPITAL ADVISORS, J.P. MORGAN
PARTNERS, THOMAS H. LEE
PARTNERS and WARBURG PINCUS LLC.
Development rights for Indonesia were awarded by KRISPY
KREME DOUGHNUTS INC . to PT PREMIER
DOUGHNUT INDONESIA, a subsidiary of PT MAP
Premier Indonesia. The agreement is for the development
of 20 Krispy Kreme shops during the next five years
with the first unit opening by the end of this month.
According to Krispy Kreme, they would not hold any
ownership stake in the franchise. Development rights
were also awarded by Krispy Kreme last May for as
many as 100 locations throughout the Middle East
to the AMERICANA GROUP, a restaurant,
food processing, distribution and retail company
that operates franchised KFC, Pizza Hut and Hardee’s
outlets.
BRIAN COOLEY , a spokesman for THE
KRYSTAL CO . was recently quoted by the
Associated Press as saying that the operator and
franchisor of 420 Krystal fast-food outlets in 12
Southern states “is still in the preliminary
stages of the process and cannot comment further
at this time” with regards to the company’s
hiring of CREDIT-SUISSE FIRST BOSTON GROUP to
help the 74-year-old chain find a buyer. In 1997,
The Krystal Co. was taken private by ROYAL
HOLDINGS INC., formed by PHILIP
H. SANFORD, a former senior
vice president of finance and administration at Atlanta-based
Coca-Cola Enterprises Inc. Corporate revenues in
2005 at The Krystal Co. have been reported as having
increased 5.5 percent to $273.7 million on systemwide
sales of $422.6 million, up 1.9 percent for the year.
PHIL GREIFELD , chief executive HUDDLE
HOUSE INC. announced that KARL MALONE, retired
National Basketball Association legend who was a
Utah Jazz All-Star and member of the first USA “Dream
Team”, is opening a branch of the family-dining
Huddle House chain in Farmerville, a northeast Louisiana
suburb located near the city of Monroe.
Chicken wing specialty chain, WINGSTOP, has
added its 300 th unit in Lancaster, California. There
are plans to have 500 outlets by 2008, 100 of them
in California according to the company.
A 12 th unit of EL POLLO LOCO has
been added in Arizona in the city of Tempe and is operated
by the company’s largest franchisee, WKS
RESTAURANT CORP. This unit is the first of
12 new branches that WKS agreed to add to its system.
Nation’s Restaurant News has awarded it’s
2006 Pioneer Award to the Ingram family, founders of
the WHITE CASTLE chain. The brother-and
sister team of BILL and DEBBIE
SHORE, founders of SHARE OUR STRENGTH, were
winners of NRA’s 2006 Innovator Award. Both awards
will be presented in Dallas on October 17 th at the
47th annual MULTI-UNIT FOODSERVICE OPERATORS conference’s
awards banquet. White Castle founder E.W. “BILLY” INGRAM’s granddaughter, MARYANN
INGRAM KELLEY, will receive the award for
the family. In response to the Ethiopian famine and
growing concern about hunger in the United States,
Bill and Debbie Shore founded Share Our Strength and
SOS has raised over $190 million to support more than
1,000 anti-hunger, anti-poverty groups worldwide.
JOHN KAUFMAN, f ormer Koo Koo Roo
and California Pizza Kitchen executive, and partner TIM
FOLEY, owner of Los Angeles-based Red Carpet
Catering, have opened an American bistro chain prototype
called TRUXTON’S in Los Angeles
with plans for five to six more openings within the
next three years.
At KFC, a division of YUM!
BRANDS, a new menu item, the Mashed Potato
Bowl, is a “convenient meal solution” according
to senior director for product innovation and development, PATTY
SCHEIBMEIR. According to Scheibmeir, “It
was difficult for customers to eat our food on the
go” as traditional fried chicken dinners leave
fingers messy and often require multiple containers
for side dishes. The issue of portability was solved
with the Mashed Potato Bowl after chefs at KFC’s
laboratory were asked to create a spin-off of the
Zesty Chicken Border Bowl from TACO BELL,
also owned by YUM! BRANDS. When discussing future
bowl products at KFC, Scheibmeir says, “It’s
a platform we hope to keep alive for the next several
years.”
Sales for PAPA JOHN’S INTERNATIONAL have
nearly doubled since NIGEL TRAVIS became
chief executive in April of 2005. In a recent interview,
Travis said that he believes the U.S. could support
about another 1,500 stores that would include a mixture
of traditional and non traditional units including
locations at airports, stadiums and hospitals. He also
indicated that they have arrangements to open 800-plus
additional international units over the next 10 years.
Travis’ philosophy is “to build on the
strengths we have and is a firm believer in communication,
holding big meetings with their franchisees twice a
year.
|
| FINANCIAL |
|
For the four weeks ended Aug. 20, PAPA JOHN’S
INTERNATIONAL, parent of the 2,964-unit pizza delivery
brand, posted a 4.4-percent same-store sales gain at
U.S. units.
Declines in same-store sales and average-unit volumes
were reported by OSI RESTAURANT PARTNERS INC. for all
but one of its restaurant brands for the four weeks
ended Aug. 26. Same-store sales at OSI’s 832-unit
OUTBACK STEAKHOUSE system fell 4.6 percent at company-owned
branches and 5.1 percent at franchised outlets. There
was a 5.2-percent drop in same-store sales at all-OSI-owned
CARRABBA’S ITALIAN GRILL, a chain of 217 units,
while those of 114-unit BONEFISH GRILL and 22-unit
ROY’S fell 1.7 percent and 3.6 percent, respectively.
At the 42-unit FLEMING’S PRIME STEAKHOUSE & WINE
BAR chain, though, same-store sales rose 2.4 percent.
Even with a 1.2-percent rise in the chain’s
average check and a 0.9-percent rise in menu prices,
CBRL GROUP INC. said that same-store restaurant sales
at its 543 Cracker Barrel Old Country Store restaurants
had fallen 1.5 percent from year-earlier levels for
the four weeks ended Aug. 25.
Shares at BRINKER INTERNATIONAL INC., the casual-dining
parent of such brands as Chili’s, Romano’s
Macaroni Grill and Maggiano’s, rose following
an announcement of a “Dutch auction” tender
offer to buy back up to about 11.7 million Brinker
shares for a maximum of $450 million.
In its third quarter ended July 13, VICORP RESTAURANTS
INC., operator and franchisor of 400 restaurants under
the family-dining brands Village Inn and Bakers Square,
reported a net loss of $581,000 versus a profit of
$1.3 million in the year-ago quarter, despite a 9-percent
jump in revenues.
For the four weeks ended Aug. 14, CKE RESTAURANTS
INC. reported a 3.8-percent blended same-store sales
increase which reflected comparable-unit sales gains
of 6.3 percent at its Carl’s Jr. chain and 1.4
percent at its Hardee’s brand.
After reports by WENDY’S INTERNATIONAL INC.
that same-store sales at corporate WENDY’S OLD
FASHIONED HAMBURGERS restaurants rose 2.5 percent in
June followed by a 3.6 percent increase in July, KERRII
ANDERSON, the company’s interim chief executive
officer, said sales numbers for August “appear
to be even better.”
A stock buyback program to repurchase up to $4 million
in shares during the next 12 months has been authorized
by ARK RESTAURANTS CORP., operator of 51 restaurants
in addition to catering and wholesale businesses in
New York, Washington, D.C., Atlantic City, N.J. and
Las Vegas.
For the four weeks ended Aug. 20, APPLEBEE’S
INTERNATIONAL INC. reported a 2.7-percent decline in
systemwide domestic same-store sales versus the same
period of a year earlier. At domestic franchised restaurants,
comparable-unit sales decreased 3.1 percent and at
corporate units fell 1.6 percent.
Because of its missed filing date for second-quarter
results, THE CHEESECAKE FACTORY INC. said that it had
received a notice of possible delisting from the Nasdaq
exchange. The company submitted to regulators a notification
of late filing because of its internal audit and SEC
inquiry into its options practices, which is still
pending.
With funds allocated for debt repayment and other
corporate purposes, including share repurchases, IHOP
CORP., franchisor and operator of 1,264 namesake family-dining
units, announced that it would borrow up to $200 million
in a private securitization. Additionally, the company
authorized a 2-million share increase to its ongoing
share buyback program.
For its second quarter ended July 11, the operator
and franchisor of 247 bakery-cafes, BRUEGGER’S
ENTERPRISES INC., reported year-over-year, same-store
sales growth of 5.8 percent at corporate locations
and 3.9 percent at franchised units.
For the four weeks ended August 12, YUM! BRANDS INC.
reported a 3-percent drop in blended same-store sales
for its U.S.-based restaurants. The biggest decline
was at Its Pizza Hut concept, who reported a same-store
sales drop of 7 percent from a year earlier.
For its second quarter, RED ROBIN GOURMET BURGERS
INC. posted slightly lower year-over-year profit even
though there was a revenue surge of 19.1 percent and
same-store sales gains of 3.3 percent at corporate
units and 2.6 percent at domestic franchised restaurants.
A 5.9- percent drop in its third-quarter profit was
reported by the STEAK N SHAKE CO., operator and franchisor
of 469 full-service, namesake restaurants. The company
said continued pressures on consumer spending had led
to a modest 1.7-percent increase in revenues and a
3.9-percent decline in same-store sales.
Approval was granted by the board for SONIC CORP.,
operator and franchisor of about 3,150 drive-ins in
the United States and Mexico, for a modified "Dutch
auction" tender offer to buy back up to about
25.5 million shares of its common stock, about 30 percent
of shares outstanding, for up to $560 million.
Second-quarter profit at TRIARC COS. INC., operator
and franchisor of the more than 3,500 ARBY’S
restaurants, rose more than sevenfold on revenues that
more than tripled to $307.8 million. Triarc earned
$3.1 million for the quarter ended July 2 versus $419,000
a year earlier.
BRINKER INTERNATIONAL INC. reported a 46.7% increase
in fourth-quarter profit in the midst of ongoing same
store sales slippage which is a reflection of the sale
of restaurants to franchisees along with a tax benefit
that helped boost results for the multichain parent
of the Chili’s Grill & Bar brand. Brinker’s
net income for the 13 weeks ended June 28 was $73 million
versus $49.8 million a year earlier.
On August 10th, a reverse stock split at a 1-for-10
ratio was declared by WESTERN SIZZLIN CORP., effectively
reducing the number of outstanding shares and boosting
its per-share price. Western Sizzlin Corp. is the operator
and franchisor of 131 restaurants under the Western
Sizzlin Steak & More, Western Sizzlin Wood Grill,
Great American Steak & Buffet Company and Quincy
Steakhouses.
Second quarter profit at LANDRY’S RESTAURANTS
INC., operator of 311 casual-dining restaurants, including
the Joe’s Crab Shack, Landry’s Seafood
House and Rainforest Cafe chains, dropped 45.3-percent.
The company attributed the drop to increased interest
expense from a 2005 refinancing, asset impairment and
store closure costs and stock based compensation expenses.
A 1.9-percent July increase in U.S. same-store sales
was reported by MCDONALD’S CORP. versus the same
month last year, marking the chain’s smallest
domestic same-store gain since April 2003 and the first
monthly dip below 2 percent since then.
A 16.6-percent jump in third-quarter profit was reported
by JACK IN THE BOX INC., operator and franchisor of
2,065 namesake restaurants, including 50 with Quick
Stuff convenience stores, and 298 Qdoba Mexican Grill
fast casual units, to $27.8 million.
A 0.6-percent increase in second-quarter profits from
a year earlier were reported by RYAN’S RESTAURANT
GROUP, which is being acquired by Buffets Inc., to
$6.9 million even though there was a 3.1-percent dip
in restaurant sales to $208.9 million. Total sales
for the five weeks ended Aug. 2 at Ryan’s declined
7 percent from a year earlier to $77.5 million.
Despite a nearly 14-percent rise in revenues to $136.2
million, compared with $119.4 million in the same quarter
last year, CALIFORNIA PIZZA KITCHEN INC., operator
and franchisor of 196 restaurants, including its namesake
casual-dining chain, the fast-casual California Pizza
Kitchen ASAP brand and an LA Food Show restaurant,
reported a 2.9-percent dip in second-quarter net income
to $6 million.
In its first-quarter NATHAN’S FAMOUS INC., operator
or franchisor of 362 restaurants under the Nathan’s
Famous, Miami Subs and Kenny Rogers Roasters brands,
reported a 19.4-percent boost to $1.4 million on revenues
that rose 7.6 percent to $12.2 million.
For the 12 weeks ended July 9, O’CHARLEY’S
INC., operator or franchisor of 356 restaurants under
the O’Charley’s, Ninety Nine and Stoney
River Legendary Steaks brands, reported a net income
of $4.4 million versus $5 million in the same period
last year. Additionally, they posted an 11.5-percent
reduction in second-quarter earnings on revenues that
rose 4.4 percent to $223.6 million, compared with a
year earlier.
Same-store sales for the four weeks ended July 26
at DENNY’S CORP. rose 3 percent at the 543 branches
owned by the company as their guest checks for the
month increased 4.2 percent.
Parent DARDEN RESTAURANTS INC. reported that same-store
sales at Red Lobster fell about 2 percent as guest
counts dipped nearly 4.5 percent and average checks
increased nearly 3 percent.
Versus the same period a year earlier, same-stores
sales at LONE STAR STEAKHOUSE & SALOON INC., operator
and franchisor of 279 restaurants, fell 5.5 percent
for the six weeks ended July 25.
For the three months ended June 25, PAPA JOHN’S
INTERNATIONAL INC., the operator and franchisor of
2,960 Papa John’s Pizza outlets reported a 1.2-percent
increase in corporate revenues to $241.6 million. They
posted a 40.3-percent jump in second-quarter net income
to $15.3 million including a net gain of $4 million
from the consolidation of the chain’s franchisee-owned
cheese purchasing company, BIBP Commodities.
For the 13 weeks ended June 25, BUCA INC., owner and
operator of 104 BUCA DI BEPPO and VINNY T’S OF
BOSTON restaurants, reported a second-quarter net loss
of $718,000 on revenues that rose 2.3 percent to $61
million.
In its first quarterly financial report since going
public in May, BURGER KINGS HOLDINGS INC., posted a
net loss of $9 million for the fourth quarter ended
June 30, despite a 6-percent increase in revenues to
$533 million.
Despite a 1-percent gain in the chain’s average
check and a 0.9-percent increase in menu prices CBRL
GROUP INC. said that same-store sales at its CRACKER
BARREL OLD COUNTRY STORE chain had fallen 2.8 percent
from year-earlier levels for the five weeks ended July
28.
|
| RESUME
TIPS |
Keep It Current!
By: Bettie Biehn
Whew! You finally dotted the final “I”,
crossed the last “t”, and ran the whole document through
spell-check for the eighth time. And you had your best friend, your
cousin the English major, and your Mom read and re-read it for content,
grammar, and punctuation. So now you’re done……
or are you?
Most of us write a resume only a few times in our lives….and
only when we’re sick and tired of our current jobs, and want
to explore some new opportunities. But my advice is: keep your resume
up-to-date at all times. You never know when you’ll need it.
After all, even if you really like your current job, your “dream” job
may just ramble across your desk or monitor, and you just have to
go for it. At that moment, you need a current resume. Or you’re
asked to make a speech, or give a presentation, and they ask you for
your current resume. You don’t have time to re-do it that quickly,
but if you had it already done, you could email them a copy. Sound
simple? It is. But you need to make yourself add that latest job,
or organization, or accomplishment to your resume soon after you add
them to your work life.
Most of my clients tell me that they needed their updated resumes
yesterday. My best advice to you is to keep your resume as current
as possible and you’ll always have it to use. It doesn’t
take much time; it mainly takes commitment and determination. Procrastination
has no place here, so go update your resume. NOW!!
Bettie
Biehn, a career human resources (HR) professional, is
founder and president of Career Change Central, LLC, a
premier resume writing and career coaching business.
Bettie is also a freelance writer, and her published
magazine articles address key HR issues. Contact Bettie
at bbiehn@careerchangecentral.com, and visit her website, www.careerchangecentral.com .
|
| SAMPLING OF CURRENT
ENGAGEMENTS |
|
Dick Wray Executive Search is pleased to report that the demand for our service
is strong.
The following list is a sampling of our current engagements.
- COO, South
- Director of Manufacturing, Northeast
- Senior Director of Franchise Operations, Southeast
- Director of Franchise Development, Midwest
- VP Construction, Midwest
- Chief Purchasing Officer, Latin America
- VP Operations, West
- VP Training, Southeast
- Director of Franchise Development, Northeast and Midwest
- Director of Operations, Various
Referrals are the lifeblood of our business. If you know of anyone who may
be interested in one of these situations, we would be happy to review their
credentials.
|
| LAGNIAPPE |
Restaurants have taken on a new prominence over
the last five years at an increasing number of shopping
centers. In the past, shopping centers relied mainly
on department stores to serve as anchor tenants, however,
many have now turned to restaurants, especially clusters
of restaurants, combined with movie theaters and bookstores
to attract shoppers. At the 200-store International
Plaza mall next to Tampa International Airport in Florida,
shoppers can eat at an indoor court that has nine fast
food establishments but they also have the choice of
15 full-service restaurants, including about a dozen
that sit within a large outdoor area adjacent to the
mall. Destination restaurants like Blue Martini, a
bar that also serves food, Bamboo Club Asian Bistro,
Café Japon and a Capital Grille steakhouse are
located at the Centers of Bloomfield Hills, Michigan.
In Eastern Town Center in Columbus, Ohio, there are
a half dozen restaurants offering both valet parking
and white tablecloths. This move towards more and better
restaurants is the result of the surging popularity
of mixed-used developments that often combine stores,
offices and residential space as well as open-air shopping
centers that use restaurants to attract shoppers. MATTHEW
K. HARDING, president and chief operating officer of
Levin Management, a retail services company in North
Plainfield, New Jersey, recently was quoted as saying “In
the past a shopping center might have had one or two
restaurants, but now we’re seeing both more restaurants
and better restaurants.” BARRY ROSENBERG, president
of Steiner & Associates, said that his company
found that 75 percent of the visitors to who came to
one of its centers to eat also bought something other
than food while they were there. Rosenberg also said, “To
us, the merchandizing mix for restaurants is as critical
as the merchandizing mix for apparel. When we look
at a center, we look at it from a restaurant standpoint,
like whether it has a great Italian restaurant, a steakhouse,
a place to go to lunch or a quick brunch, or a place
to go for a business dinner.”
|
| HOSPITALITY - HOTELS |
|
Time-share properties are steadily expanding into
the big cities including New York. MATT AVRIL, president
and managing director of Starwood Vacation Ownership,
a division of STARWOOD HOTELS AND RESORTS WORLDWIDE
was recently quoted as saying, “The trend to
bring this type of product to an urban environment
is clearly growing, and what better urban environment
than New York.” Earlier this year, Starwood began
selling time shares at the St. Regis Hotel in New York
City. HILTON HOTELS converted two floors of its flagship
hotel, the Hilton New York into 78 time-share units
several years ago and called it the Hilton Club. This
past June, Hilton bought a premium site in Midtown
Manhattan and according to industry analysts, the property
could become part of the Hilton Grand Vacations time-share
chain. MARRIOTT VACATION CLUB INTERNATIONAL’s
vice president of corporate affairs and brand awareness,
EDWARD F. KINNEY, said urban properties are “great
to have as an added dimension to what you offer.” He
added, “But they are a little challenging in
that cost of construction and redevelopment is higher
than a traditional resort property. You can’t
always have the same amenities you would in a resort
environment, and you have to charge more for the product.” Marriott
was the first of the major hotels to expand into the
time shares in the 1980’s. Investors, however,
know that time-shares don’t always appreciate
like other real estate. HOWARD C. NUSBAUM, president
and chief executive of the American Resort Development
Association said, “The value proposition is in
the use. You don’t buy them because you’re
looking for a real estate appreciation.”
Last year, U.S. investors pumped $6.8 billion into
hotel purchases in Europe, representing about a third
of European hotel deals as private-equity firms are
continuing to purchase European hotels. Often, hotels
can offer the buyer returns that exceed 20% and the
sales enable hotel operators to focus on franchising,
lightening debt loads and executing share buybacks
boosting their stock price. Last month, HILTON HOTELS
CORP. announced that it is considering the sale of
all or part of its Scandic brand of hotels located
primarily in Sweden, Norway, Finland and Denmark. Additionally
Hilton International has intentions of selling 10 hotels
in Europe in Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg,
Spain and Switzerland. INTERCONTINENTAL HOTELS GROUP
PLC has been another active seller in the last three
years selling 173 hotels with a net asset value of
$5.3 billion. STARWOOD CAPITAL GROUP GLOBAL LLC and
BLACKSTONE GROUP have also been active buyers in the
past three months.
|
|
|
|